Moi on m'a dit : Nyala, c'est un analphabète, il sait pas lire ni écrire

Lol, you're ridiculous, you've caught just the nicknames part (and I'm not saying that it's a big problem, but here I see your seriousness)

Apart from that, I haven't complained about the general ranking, just the fact that Koys hasn't respected the rules and he should have receive at least a penalisation, because it's not correct towards of other participants.
I would have appreciate if the rules (not made by me) had been respected.

Kscarlet wrote:

About Koys, without mentioning the fact that I didn't like it, wasn't the minimum lenght 2 minutes? Because his video is 1:45 minutes long, why wasn't he disqualified? Then again, if you didn't want to disqualify it, why haven't you penalized it? Ooh yes, Soul's Team member..

Spoiler:

i really hope that you are not an iilliterate person and that you can read that his clip is 2:14 ( 2:00 exactly without Outro )

I'm not from the Soul's team, and seriously i find that Creed and Nyala was really Objectives, so i thank them for that, it was really nice to work with them, we watched 96 clips, and judged them ...So if you really find that the soul's team members are higher than "other" that only means that they deserve this place ( specially Dn@ for his first place )

And about the nicknames, please guys, we're human, so we can do mistakes =/ ...Beside we were really tired and that wasn't a piece of cake ...so i'll ask you to be understandable

Anyway, i'm really glad to see that most of participant are satisfied by the results ...Don't forget that all of this is for fun, and i think that most of you had fun in this IC ( and most of you did find theire taste in the musics pack )

Congrats to everyone, and next IC you'll find me as a particpant

I didn't say I was satisfied by the results Angie : o

you did better than me though MimS, don't complain (and they DIDN'T mispell my nickname like last year! (Y)) xD next time I'll make the organizers do an IC with the songs I like, let's see how they will like it!

Yeah, but, seriously, my vid is better than Dn@'s one |:

well I don't know, I haven't really watched the videos xD whatever >.<

MimS wrote:

I didn't say I was satisfied by the results Angie : o

angelface wrote:

Anyway, i'm really glad to see that most of participant are satisfied by the results

MOST ...MOST ! not all

C'est impossible dans un concours de voir que tous le monde soient satisfait , c'est pas le monde des bisounours x)

angelface wrote:

Kscarlet wrote:

About Koys, without mentioning the fact that I didn't like it, wasn't the minimum lenght 2 minutes? Because his video is 1:45 minutes long, why wasn't he disqualified? Then again, if you didn't want to disqualify it, why haven't you penalized it? Ooh yes, Soul's Team member..

Spoiler:

i really hope that you are not an iilliterate person and that you can read that his clip is 2:14 ( 2:00 exactly without Outro )

I'm not from the Soul's team, and seriously i find that Creed and Nyala was really Objectives, so i thank them for that, it was really nice to work with them, we watched 96 clips, and judged them ...So if you really find that the soul's team members are higher than "other" that only means that they deserve this place ( specially Dn@ for his first place )

And about the nicknames, please guys, we're human, so we can do mistakes =/ ...Beside we were really tired and that wasn't a piece of cake ...so i'll ask you to be understandable

Anyway, i'm really glad to see that most of participant are satisfied by the results ...Don't forget that all of this is for fun, and i think that most of you had fun in this IC ( and most of you did find theire taste in the musics pack )

Congrats to everyone, and next IC you'll find me as a particpant

The video is 1:45 minutes long because it's 1:58 without ending, 1:53 without intro, and almost 1:45 if we don't consider the initial 8/9 mute seconds. So I just wanted a penalisation.
And I've complained only about the Koys position, not of all the Soul's Team members. I don't agree with your way to judge, I'm not saying that you've done preferences.

Someone want something from me...

Why you getting mad your clip was just not enough good, editing>rules that's it

And mystyk and angel, mims was just joking

MagicDarkLight wrote:

And mystyk and angel, mims was just joking

Yep i realized that after i read his second post
And i was tired to edit my post x)

Next time MimS, i'm sure that you'll be higher than Dn@ ...you'll have the 0 place


Edit : vas y vous êtes des francophones, je ne comprend pas pourquoi je vous répond en anglais xD

mdrr trop ca moi jmettais mystyk avec en fait xD

ahahahahaha

but seriously, are you free at one of the weekends? (the organizers) Angel, Nyala, Creed? I'LL MAKE YOU SUFFER FROM MY MUSIC! xD jk (but who knows) >.<

ahahahahaha loooool so MDL is cruel cuz he is laughing at my stupidity? grrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr I'LL MAKE YOU SUFFER EVEN MOREEEEEEE!!!!!!!!!!

Bon pour répondre aux différentes polémiques qui surgissent déjà :

Concernant le clip de Koys (1:54 - 1:55 ; je ne sais pas où vous allez chercher vos 1:45) la marge de 10% de disqualification a été respectée). Si tu t'inquiètes tant pour les pénalisations, sache que Koys a été pénalisé dans sa position à cause des 5-6 secondes manquantes (et un cut audio des plus original mais j'y reviendrai plus tard).

Rien à voir avec les 25 ou 1:30 temps non effectuées dans certains clips.


De plus, le système de classement des équipes prends bien en compte la valeur du taux de participation selon les catégories comme je l'ai déjà énoncé.
Et je me souviens bien vous avoir largement prévenu concernant les catégories vides qui permettaient aux participants d'obtenir de meilleurs places pour les classements collectifs, c'était ça la stratégie. Vous aviez des tableaux avec tous les éditeurs par catégorie et tenus à jour, mais ça bien sûr personne ne s'en souvient

Nyala wrote:

Bon pour répondre aux différentes polémiques qui surgissent déjà :

Concernant le clip de Koys (1:54 - 1:55 ; je ne sais pas où vous allez chercher vos 1:45) la marge de 10% de disqualification a été respectée). Si tu t'inquiètes tant pour les pénalisations, sache que Koys a été pénalisé dans sa position à cause des 5-6 secondes manquantes (et un cut audio des plus original mais j'y reviendrai plus tard).

Rien à voir avec les 25 ou 1:30 temps non effectuées dans certains clips.


De plus, le système de classement des équipes prends bien en compte la valeur du taux de participation selon les catégories comme je l'ai déjà énoncé.
Et je me souviens bien vous avoir largement prévenu concernant les catégories vides qui permettaient aux participants d'obtenir de meilleurs places pour les classements collectifs, c'était ça la stratégie. Vous aviez des tableaux avec tous les éditeurs par catégorie et tenus à jour, mais ça bien sûr personne ne s'en souvient

Could you write it in English, please?
I'm not sure to have understood with Google Translate.

Koys wrote:

Someone want something from me...

I don't want nothing from you, it's just that your video doesn't follow the rules, and I would have appreciated a penalisation or something similar.

Parfait mon clip

He said Koys did got penalisation, it was like 10% of his points if I understand it well (anyways he got penalisation). BUT he wasn't disqualified as some of the amvs which were just 1:35 or less.
----
And Luciole said "Perfect my clip" and he has bien raison

MagicDarkLight wrote:

He said Koys did got penalisation, it was like 10% of his points if I understand it well (anyways he got penalisation). BUT he wasn't disqualified as some of the amvs which were just 1:35 or less.
----
And Luciole said "Perfect my clip" and he has bien raison

ok thx.

------------------------

Nyala wrote:

Bon pour répondre aux différentes polémiques qui surgissent déjà :

Concernant le clip de Koys (1:54 - 1:55 ; je ne sais pas où vous allez chercher vos 1:45) la marge de 10% de disqualification a été respectée). Si tu t'inquiètes tant pour les pénalisations, sache que Koys a été pénalisé dans sa position à cause des 5-6 secondes manquantes (et un cut audio des plus original mais j'y reviendrai plus tard).

Rien à voir avec les 25 ou 1:30 temps non effectuées dans certains clips.


De plus, le système de classement des équipes prends bien en compte la valeur du taux de participation selon les catégories comme je l'ai déjà énoncé.
Et je me souviens bien vous avoir largement prévenu concernant les catégories vides qui permettaient aux participants d'obtenir de meilleurs places pour les classements collectifs, c'était ça la stratégie. Vous aviez des tableaux avec tous les éditeurs par catégorie et tenus à jour, mais ça bien sûr personne ne s'en souvient

And where was written this thing of the 10%? I've read the rules and I haven't found it.

bad translation. Koys made a shorter video but its over 90% of time demanded. So they didnt disqualify him cause its too close from 2min, but it was a bad point for judges thus he lost some points for that.

Kscarlet wrote:

Koys wrote:

Someone want something from me...

I don't want nothing from you, it's just that your video doesn't follow the rules, and I would have appreciated a penalisation or something similar.

I made only 1:35 and i was disqualified. Koys made 1:55, that's only 5s unedited.
Why do you want to penalize Koys as much as me ?

I'm neither pro-soul-team nor con-soul-team, but i think you're too merciless.

Hige-san wrote:

Kscarlet wrote:

Koys wrote:

Someone want something from me...

I don't want nothing from you, it's just that your video doesn't follow the rules, and I would have appreciated a penalisation or something similar.

I made only 1:35 and i was disqualified. Koys made 1:55, that's only 5s unedited.
Why do you want to penalize Koys as much as me ?

I'm neither pro-soul-team nor con-soul-team, but i think you're too merciless.

Actually, his video is 1:45 minutes long (as I've already said, he left almost 10 seconds mute). Anyway I've never said that I wanted that he should have been disqualified, but that he should have receive a real penalisation, and not just few points.

Kscarlet wrote:

I've never said that I wanted that he should have been disqualified, but that he should have receive a real penalisation, and not just few points.

Ok, so what kind of "real" penalisation do you propose ?
That's an AMV Iron Chef, judges don't have many possibilities to penalize him.

Sacré Scarlet